Imaging "Slavery" in MT's Books

WAITING FOR A TRIP
CLICK FOR MORE IMAGE & TEXT
  The ongoing challenges to Huck Finn as racist in its representation of slavery and African Americans have prompted a heightened scholarly interest in trying to determine exactly what Samuel Clemens' ideas on those subjects were. All accounts agree that his ideas changed drastically over time. Although the Missouri he grew up in never joined the Confederacy, it was a world in which slavery was taken for granted by most whites, defended by all public institutions, including the churches, and attacked out loud by no one; Sam's own parents owned slaves. The Langdon family his wife belonged to, on the other hand, was actively abolitionist, and by the time Sam married into it at the start of his career the U.S. had abolished slavery. As an owner/editor of the Buffalo Express in 1869 he wrote and printed an unsigned editorial protesting the recent lynching of a black man in Memphis; in 1881 he wrote President-elect Garfield a letter on behalf of Frederick Douglass; in 1885, in acknowledgment of the rights of former slaves to reparation for the wrongs that white America had done them, he arranged to help support an African American named Warner T. McGuinn through Yale law school. (You can see MT's letter to Garfield in the SAM CLEMENS AS MARK TWAIN section of the archive. The best account of slavery in Sam Clemens' Hannibal is Searching for Jim, by Terrell Dempsey [2003]; a representative account of how the adult Samuel Clemens personally thought and talked about slavery and race is Lighting Out for the Territory, by Shelley Fisher Fishkin [1997].)
  But when Twainians cite these kinds of biographical facts to answer the critique of Huck Finn, they overlook the crucial distinction between what Sam Clemens thought or did in private (what we know about his personal life), and what "Mark Twain" wrote or what "the writings of Mark Twain" say (what his audience saw in his published books). The end of slavery did not mean America was finished with such questions as what was slavery like? or what does its existence mean about our past? Most of MT's major writings are set in slave-owning societies -- how do they re-present slavery for an American reading public that was struggling to come to terms with slavery, indeed that continues to be be haunted by those questions today?
  For his contemporaries, MT's books were made of pictures as well as words, and for many of those readers the pictures would have spoken at least as loudly as the words. This page brings together some of MT's published words about slavery with many of the pictures that appeared in the first editions of his books. My goal is to give you a way to see the images of slavery that readers in his times saw through the windows onto that world that his books gave them.
AUNT RACHEL
CLICK FOR MORE IMAGE & TEXT
  MT's first contribution to The Atlantic Monthly was also his first substantial representation of the experience of slavery. In "A True Story, Repeated Word for Word as I Heard It" (November 1874), "Misto C----" listens as Aunt Rachel tells him "all 'bout slavery." Her story begins with an account of the horrifying auction in Richmond at which she and her seven children were sold apart, and ends when, near the end of the Civil War, she was reunited with her youngest son, now a soldier in a "colored regiment" in the Union Army. Although some of its original readers, knowing it was "By Mark Twain," apparently kept looking for a joke in it, it is a moving story, and THE MANUSCRIPT shows how seriously MT worked to get Rachel's voice right. He reprinted the story in Sketches, New and Old (1875), where True Williams' illustration of Rachel at left appeared.


            "Old Times on the Mississippi"        

  MT's next contribution to the Atlantic was the series of sketches about his experiences as an apprentice steamboat pilot on "the Southern trade" in the late 1850s. These were published in seven installments between January and July, 1875, under the title "Old Times on the Mississippi." Rooted in nostalgia for the riverboats' "days of glory," MT's narrative almost completely ignores the role slavery played in steamboating -- that the boats' crews were mainly slaves, and that slaves as well as cotton were their staple cargoes. Mr. Bixby, who plays master pilot to the narrator's cub, lands a steamboat at a plantation in the pitch dark as an example of his prowess, but the darkness also makes both the plantation and the slave who waits on the shore invisible -- we can only hear "a darky's voice" saying "'Gimme de k'yarpet-bag, Mars' Jones.'" The Atlantic texts were unillustrated, but MT incorporated the sketches into Life on the Mississippi (1883), where the illustrations below, by John Harley, show how this version of the "Old Times" represented slavery:

ALL GO HURRYING TO THE WHARF
I'LL FETCH IT!
SUBLIME IN PROFANITY
LET THE LEADSMAN CRY OUT
COME IN DE HOUSE DIS MINUTE
THE PARTING CHORUS
CLICK ANY ICON FOR MORE IMAGE & TEXT


            The Adventures of Tom Sawyer        

  The word "slave" appears twice in MT's first fiction about the world of his childhood, in the Preface and in a footnote. In the text of the novel itself we meet Jim, identified only as Aunt Polly's "small colored boy," and hear about the unnamed "negro" who has just taught Tom a new way to whistle, about the "[w]hite, mulatto and negro boys and girls" who congregate at the town pump, and about "Uncle Jake," "Ben Roger's . . . pap's nigger." But slavery is barely mentioned. When the narrator talks about "captivity and fetters," he's referring to Tom having to go to school, and he uses the slogan of the Anti-Slavery movement -- "Am I not a man and a brother, without distinction of color" -- to make a joke about the way Tom's face looks after his sister Mary has washed it. More than Polly's fence gets white-washed in the story, but evading the presence of slavery is one of the most powerful means by which MT's story creates such an inviting past for his readers' nostalgia to inhabit. (For more on Tom Sawyer as a mythic representation of the nation's history, see ST. PETERSBURG AND AMERICAN NOSTALGIA in the archive's TOM SAWYER section.) True Williams drew the pictures for Tom Sawyer, and represents "slaves" in the series below:

JIM
TENDIN TO BUSINESS
[THE STRANGLING HERO]
HAPPY FOR TWO DAYS
UNCLE JAKE
CLICK ANY ICON FOR MORE IMAGE & TEXT


            Adventures of Huckleberry Finn        

  When MT next goes back to St. Petersburg, slavery plays a much larger role in the story he tells, but how Huck Finn represents slaves and slavery remains a very controversial question. Throughout the novel Huck (as someone who's been raised in a slave-holding society) believes slavery is right; though he likes Jim and is willing to "go to hell" to "steal Jim out of slavery," he expresses more sympathy for Miss Watson as the "poor old woman" who owns Jim than for Jim himself. By 1885, slavery had been abolished for two decades, so nearly every contemporary reader would see Huck's belief in its eternal rightness ironically, as an example of another kind of "slavery" -- the way a child's mind is captive to the values of the society she or he is born into.
  But even after slavery has been abolished, there remains the problem of understanding what it was like, what its legacy is, what it says about the nation's culture. And what remains ambiguous about the novel is the way it presents slavery: the idea of slavery that its words and pictures leave in the minds of its readers. From the first edition's 174 drawings by E. W. Kemble, who was picked by MT himself to illustrate the novel, I selected the 16 below as representative of the way contemporary readers were shown the slave-owning society through which Huck and Jim travel.

JIM
MISTO BRADISH'S NIGGER
HIM AND ANOTHER MAN
BOY, THAT'S A LIE
HERE I IS, HUCK
THE HOUSE
ANOTHER LITTLE JOB
THE AUCTION
VITTLES
THE BREAKFAST HORN
TOM ADVISES A WITCH PIE
MISSUS, DEY'S A SHEET GONE
JIM'S COAT OF ARMS
IRRIGATION
THE DOCTOR SPEAKS FOR JIM
OUT OF BONDAGE
CLICK ANY ICON FOR MORE IMAGE & TEXT

            "then he drops down on his knees..."        

Kemble also did the illustrations for the new editions of Huck Finn that appeared in the late 1890s, and you can see them by CLICKING HERE. Of course every one of Kemble's 28 pictures of "Jim" is an image of slavery. In the HUCK FINN section of the archive you can look forward from Kemble at how the novel's 12 American illustrators between 1885 and 1985 RE-PRESENTED JIM. The images below are intended to give you one way to look backward: to locate Kemble's pictures in the context of other culturally well-known representations of slaves:

JIM SEES A GHOST
ANTI-SLAVERY SOCIETY EMBLEM
ROBINSON CRUSOE AND FRIDAY
UNCLE TOM AND ST. CLARE
UNCLE TOM AND CHRIST
THE EMANCIPATION PROCLAMATION
BY RIGHTS I AM A DUKE
PERCY DRISCOLL AND HIS SLAVES
TOM KNEELING TO ROXY
CLICK ANY ICON FOR MORE IMAGE & TEXT


            Pudd'nhead Wilson        

  About 10 years after finishing Huck Finn MT decided to go back again imaginatively to the world of his childhood. The story he wound up writing, about a slave mother who tries to free her infant son by switching him with her master's baby, makes Pudd'nhead Wilson MT's most sustained engagement with the institution of slavery. What it's saying about slavery, however, is by no means clear. As published, his story was illustrated in an unusual way, with hundreds of pen-and-ink "marginal illustrations" by F. M. Senior and C. H. Warren. Their images of slaves are as ambiguous as MT's text, ranging from sentimental to realistic to minstrel grotesque. The 18 examples of their work below are chosen to represent this range. The overall effect of using "marginal illustrations," though, is to keep the reader at a great distance from the narrative, to turn the characters into cartoons, and, since shading is impossible, to eliminate any kind of grey area between "black" and "white." (You can see all the illustrations in the DIGITAL FACSIMILE of the First edition in the PUDD'NHEAD WILSON section of the archive. When the novel appeared serially in The Century, it was illustrated by one of the magazine's staff artists, Louis Loeb, whose drawings, including 3 of slaves, can be seen on the ILLUSTRATING PUDD'NHEAD page; there you can also see the 7 new illustrations that E. W. Kemble drew for a late 1890s edition -- slaves appear in 5 of those.)

SLAVE WORKED COUNTRY
ROXY AND JASPER
PERCY DRISCOLL AND HIS SLAVES
ROXY'S TERROR
PERCY DRISCOLL DISCIPLINES CHAMBERS
TOM STRIKING ROXY
JUDGE DRISCOLL BUYS CHAMBERS
RECEPTION FOR THE TWINS
ROXY'S RETURN TO THE VILLAGE
ROXY STRIKES A MASTERFUL ATTITUDE
THE DUEL
THE ELECTION CAMPAIGN
DE LAW KIN SELL ME NOW
HOW HAPPY THE SLAVES WERE
ROXY SOLD DOWN THE RIVER
ROXY'S LIFE DOWNRIVER (1)
ROXY'S LIFE DOWNRIVER (2)
ROXY'S LIFE DOWNRIVER (3)
RUNAWAY SLAVE POSTER
ROXY'S PLAN TO LIF' DAT ROOF
THE CREDITORS CAME FORWARD
CLICK ANY ICON FOR MORE IMAGE & TEXT


            Those Extraordinary Twins        

  In the U.S. The Tragedy of Pudd'nhead Wilson was published with The Comedy of Those Extraordinary Twins, the uncompleted farce about "Siamese" (or conjoined) twins that MT originally intended to set on the scene of Dawson's Landing. This representation of a slaveholding village recalls Tom Sawyer: boys and aunts are at the center, and slavery is only a peripheral element. But the text does include several mentions of the slaves on whose labor the "white village" depended, and among its 200 or so "marginal illustrations" are several graphic representations of slavery.

TWO NEGRO MEN ENTERED
THE SLAVE-WENCH NANCY
THE NEGRO GIRL NANCY
THE DUEL
GET THEIR BED READY
NANCY AND ROWENA IN THE KITCHEN
CLICK ANY ICON FOR MORE IMAGE & TEXT


            American Slavery in Other MT Texts        

  My goal in this exhibit is to give you examples of all that "Mark Twain" wrote and published, and that the illustrations of his works showed, about American slavery. The 4 examples below are from (1) "A Private History of a Campaign That Failed" (1885), (2) Following the Equator (1897), (3) "My First Lie and How I Got Out of It" (1899), and (4) the newspaper publication of his Chapters from My Autobiography (1908). (2) and (4) contain MT's longest, most expressive discussions of his own experience of slavery, at home and in Hannibal -- though it is, as always, up to each of us to decide what we think is being expressed. (If you can think of any other representations of slavery that MT himself published during his lifetime, please let me know.)

PRIVATE HISTORY OF A CAMPAIGN THAT FAILED
FOLLOWING THE EQUATOR
MY FIRST LIE
MT'S AUTOBIOGRAPHY
CLICK ANY ICON FOR MORE IMAGE & TEXT


            A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court        

  "A SLAVE! Do ye understand that word!" This protest rings out from one of the unfortunate characters in MT's Prince and the Pauper (1882). Hearing how harshly this man has been treated, the exiled Prince vows to abolish the law that made his enslavement possible, but as the man himself notes, he stands before MT's reader as specifically "An English SLAVE!--that is he that stands before ye." No American slave ever voices a similar protest in MT's published books. "The most of King Arthur's British nation were slaves," writes Hank Morgan, the narrator of the novel that MT published between Huck Finn and Pudd'nhead Wilson. In Connecticut Yankee (1889) the past he depicts is the 6th century England he had read about in Malory and Scott, not the ante bellum South he grew up in. Slavery and anti-slavery play large roles in Hank's story. In Roxy's narrative in Pudd'nhead Wilson New England "Yanks" are said to make the most heartless slave owners, but MT's Connecticut Yankee is a devout abolitionist whose critique of slavery in this text is much more outspoken than any of the narrators of MT's works depicting slavery in America. The novel's illustrations are much more graphic in depicting the horrors of slavery too. They are by Dan Beard, who was himself a politically engaged social critic. Beard's temperament, as well as Hank's direct attacks on slavery, may account for the anti-slavery force of the illustrations, but their representation of slavery may also reflect the fact that in Connecticut Yankee the slaves are all "white," and the people who enslave them are not American.

A BAND OF SLAVES
BROTHER--TO DIRT LIKE THAT?
THE REAR OF HIS PROCESSION
HE WAS A MAN
ON THE TRAMP
SLAVES WARMING THEMSELVES
THE SLAVE DRIVER
HE LAY THERE IN A HEAP
CLICK ANY ICON FOR MORE IMAGE & TEXT


            Kemble's Images of African Slavery        

  How much easier it is to see something when there is no way for guilt, personal or collective, to get in the way may be what the drawings below also illustrate. They are by E. W. Kemble, the artist who illustrated every edition of Huck Finn published in MT's lifetime, and who became a specialist (as he puts it) in "negroes." Kemble's work appeared in several volumes in Joel Chander Harris' Uncle Remus series and in many magazines. He also collected them for books like Kemble's Coons (1897) and Comical Coons (1898). From 1885 through the first couple decades of the 20th century, white America loved his usually clownish and always stereotypical representations of blacks. The pictures he drew for an article titled "The Slave-Trade in the Congo Basin" (Century Magazine, February 1890), however, do not stereotype blacks or slaves. I think these pictures almost speak for themselves, not just about slavery but also about why it's so hard for American culture to get beyond caricatures and myths about slavery: now that Kemble is depicting slavery somewhere else, so that American whites need feel no responsibility for it, he draws slaves with human faces instead of blackface minstrel masks, and depicts their human suffering realistically. Compare these drawings to his work on Huck Finn, or the other Kemble illustrations further down this page, and see if you don't see the same thing yourself.

LOLO MAN
LOLO WOMAN
A SLAVE SHED
A CAPTIVE
A LEFEMBÉ SLAVE-HUNTER
A SLAVER'S CANOE
CLICK TO ENLARGE IMAGES


            Some Contemporary Images        

  In his times, the words and pictures in MT's books were read and seen in a very different cultural context than ours. To appreciate the way his work re-presents slavery it helps to see the kinds of images Americans were familiar with from other popular sources. The examples below afford only a few glimpses into that scene, but I've chosen them for their representativeness. Almost all come from the decade in which both Huck Finn and Pudd'nhead Wilson -- MT's two fullest treatments of ante bellum slavery -- were published, i.e. the mid-1880s to the mid-1890s.
  This first sequence, though, starts in the 1840s, which is when Blackface Minstrelsy erupted onto the American cultural scene. The minstrel show, which claimed to represent African Americans and the lives of slaves on the plantation through the singing, dancing and comedy routines of white men "blacked up" with burnt cork, was the single most popular form of live entertainment in the U.S. until the late 19th century, when it began giving way to vaudeville. Most of the materials below are sheet music covers, but there is one example of the minstrel joke book too. Several of the artists featured were themselves African American, including the composer James Bland and the Johnson Brothers (one of whom was James Weldon Johnson, the writer), but the conventions governing the representation of "blacks" were defined by white publishers for white audiences.
  MT loved the minstrel show, and often borrowed from its conventions in his humorous pieces. More significantly, the caricatures and images of minstrelsy were the chief means by which many white Americans in MT's time "saw" slaves and freed blacks.

THE VIRGINIA MINSTRELS
OLD DAN EMMIT'S BANJO MELODIES
BONE SQUASH'S BLACK JOKE ALMANAC
DEAR OLD HOME
BY THE MOONLIGHT
THE OLD CABIN HOME
OH DEM GOLDEN SLIPPERS
MOONLIGHT ON THE MISSISSIPPI
CLICK TO ENLARGE IMAGES

  Uncle Tom's Cabin came out of copyright in 1892, which led to dozens of new editions from various publishers, most of them illustrated (even E. W. Kemble did a 2-volume edition for Houghton Mifflin that year, with over 140 illustrations). These thousands of images are another good set of windows through which we can still look to see how MT's times "saw" slavery -- and you can see many of them in the ILLUSTRATING UTC section of my other electronic archive, Uncle Tom's Cabin & American Culture. But while Stowe's book was still popular in the 1880s and 1890s, millions of Americans every year experienced her story through The Tom Shows: traveling dramatizations that featured street parades, animals, and lots of musical numbers. Legree remained a villain who beat Tom to death at the play's climax, but in general the slaves on stage (often played by "genuine colored people," who were advertised as having been "slaves before the war") sing and dance happily. Even slave auction scenes typically served as an occasion for "buck-and-wing dancing" or "cake-walking."

TOM SHOW PAMPHLET (1)
TOM SHOW PAMPHLET (2)
TOM SHOW PAMPHLET (3)
TOM SHOW PAMPHLET (4)
STANDARD UTC COMBINATION
LIFE IN THE SUNNY SOUTH
2 TOPSYS
C H SMITH'S MAMMOTH UTC
CLICK TO ENLARGE IMAGES

  In this next set of images you can see how "slavery" appeared in a year's worth of issues of The Century Magazine, the popular national periodical that also published excerpts from Huck, Connecticut Yankee and Pudd'nhead. The year is 1890, and the drawings (many by E. W. Kemble) illustrate the three "plantation tales" printed in the magazine during that year.

HOW SAL CAME THROUGH (1)
HOW SAL CAME THROUGH (2)
HOW SAL CAME THROUGH (3)
HOW SAL CAME THROUGH (4)
TRAVIS AND MAJOR WILBY
HOW JERRY BOUGHT MALVINY (1)
HOW JERRY BOUGHT MALVINY (1)
HOW JERRY BOUGHT MALVINY (1)
CLICK TO ENLARGE IMAGES


  Plantation tales emerged in the 1880s. Their authors were white Southerners, although the tales were extremely popular throughout the North, and although they typically featured as story-tellers former slaves, who spoke in "black" dialect about life on "de old plantation." As a genre, the tales are drenched in nostalgia for that world. Even the slaves (as Joel Chandler Harris wrote in 1880 in his introduction to Uncle Remus) have "nothing but pleasant memories of the discipline of slavery." Sam, the "blackvoice" narrator inside Thomas Nelson Page's "Marse Chan" (1884), usually cited as the first full-blown plantation tale, goes even further, telling the white frame narrator that his life as a slave before Emancipation "wuz good ole times, marster--de bes' Sam ever see! Dey wuz, in fac'! Niggers didn' hed nothin' 't all to do--jes' hed to 'ten' to de feedin' an' cleanin' de hosses, an' doin' what de marster tell 'em to do." White American readers bought this fiction again and again, and the images of masters and slaves that illustrated the plantation tales played a major role in shaping the way MT's times "saw" slavery.
  The incredible success of Harris' first book about Uncle Remus led to a series of sequels. The set of illustrations below are from two books he published in 1892: On the Plantation and Uncle Remus and His Friends. The first group are by E. W. Kemble; the second, by A. B. Frost, another book and magazine illustrator who specialized in "southern" material.


ON THE PLANTATION (1)
ON THE PLANTATION (2)
ON THE PLANTATION (3)
ON THE PLANTATION (4)
ON THE PLANTATION (5)
ON THE PLANTATION (6)
ON THE PLANTATION (7)
REMUS AND FRIENDS (1)
REMUS AND FRIENDS (2)
REMUS AND FRIENDS (3)
CLICK TO ENLARGE IMAGES


  The first of Page's many books about the ante bellum South was In Ole Virginia. This collection of tales that originally appeared in magazines was published in New York by Scribner's in 1887. After it went through a number of reprintings, Scribner's decided in 1896 to bring out a new edition, with 24 full-page illustrations. 12 of these are available below. They are the work of 5 different artists, but as you can see, all share the same romantic vision not just of the aristocratic life led by the ladies and gentlemen on the big plantations, but also of relations between these generous masters and their loving slaves.

MARSE CHAN (1)
MARSE CHAN (2)
MARSE CHAN (3)
UNC' EDINBURG (1)
UNC' EDINBURG (2)
UNC' EDINBURG (3)
UNC' EDINBURG (4)
MEH LADY
OLE STRACTED (1)
OLE STRACTED (2)
POLLY (1)
POLLY (2)
CLICK TO ENLARGE IMAGES


  MT's times bought more tickets to Tom Shows than copies of his books, but his books were among the era's most popular and widely known representations of slavery. When they looked through the words and pictures in those books as windows onto the world of American slavery, what did his contemporaries see? Reviewers seldom discuss this theme directly, though you can search for a word like slave in the archive's SEARCH THE REVIEWS to approach the question from that direction. In her The Southern Magazine review of the first two installments of Pudd'nhead Wilson, for instance, another Southern writer, the novelist Martha McCulloch Williams, says that MT's work was a caricature of the slave-owners: "To [MT's] mind, the only man worth either saving or damning in all the South country is the black man." On the other hand, in January 1889 MT actually substituted for Thomas Nelson Page at a benefit lecture in Baltimore, which suggests that to some in the audience both men shared, these two Southern-born and -raised writers whose best-known fictions depicted slavery, weren't ideologically incompatible.

  No one reads Page anymore, but MT's works continue to be read inside and outside America's classrooms. What is the story they tell about slavery? That question, while it may never yield an answer everyone agrees on, should not be evaded or repressed.

[SPECIAL THANKS TO THE MARK TWAIN FORUM, ESPECIALLY BARBARA SCHMIDT & WOLFGANG HOCHBRUCK.]


To MT IN HIS TIMES Homepage   To Pudd'nhead Homepage   Back to Huck Finn Homepage   MT Bibliography